Jay Mandel

TrustGap / A practical approach by Jay Mandel

Trust starts with a promise.
Your actions prove it.

The trust gap is the distance between what your company promises and what people experience.

Find the gap. Choose what to fix. Give your team a clear way to follow through.

How trust supports the business

Seven ways to check your promise.

Choose a principle. Read the question. Start with one practical action, then expand the example for context.

Each principle includes an example from my published writing, dated for context. These are my observations and analysis, not client case studies or current company ratings. The suggested changes show how I would apply my method; they are not reported outcomes.

My methodology / Three steps

Close the gap between
your promise and their experience.

Seven principles tell us where to look. Three steps turn what we learn into action.

YOUR PROMISEWhat was promised?
↔THE TRUST GAP
THE EXPERIENCEWhat happened?
01Identity

Clarify the promise.

What should people be able to count on?

YOU LEAVE WITHA clear promise, backed by evidence.
02Intention

Choose the change.

What needs to improve, and who owns it?

YOU LEAVE WITHPriorities, owners, and measures.
03Implementation

Make it happen.

What will your team do differently?

YOU LEAVE WITHA practical plan to test and review.
01

Customer accountability

Deliver the experience you promise.

Can a customer understand your offer, receive the value, and get useful help?

Start here

Follow one customer experience from the first advertisement through purchase, support, and cancellation. Compare what you promise with what the customer can actually do.

See the consequences, example, and how I can help

How it strengthens your company

Clear prices, usable service, and straightforward recovery give people reasons to stay and recommend you.

What can weaken trust

Unexpected fees, confusing terms, or repeated handoffs can turn a sale into complaints, cancellations, and extra service work.

From my articles / These Are the Breaks / October 27, 2026

FOX: a casual viewer meets a subscription funnel.

Where it went wrong: I described a YouTube viewing experience that showed a single fielder while promoting Fox One. I wanted one game; the path in front of me centered on recurring billing. The opportunity to welcome a viewer became frustration.

What a company could do differently

  1. Identity: Define a useful experience for an occasional fan.
  2. Intention: Make the viewing options, price, and subscription commitment clear before asking for a card.
  3. Implementation: Test the journey with a first-time viewer. Explain exactly what the free stream shows and offer a clear route to the full game.
Read the original: Fox: Take Me Out to the Billing Department ↗

What I can help you do

Customer experience and workflow review. Trace one customer experience and turn the findings into a promise, handoff, or service improvement with a named owner.

02

Data accountability

Give people choices you can honor.

Do people understand what information you collect, why you use it, and the choices they have?

Start here

Choose one customer data flow. Record its source, purpose, permissions, access, and retention. Check that a customer’s preference reaches every team and supplier using it.

See the consequences, example, and how I can help

How it strengthens your company

Clear choices and respectful data use give customers a basis for sharing information with confidence.

What can weaken trust

Unexpected uses or preferences that do not carry through your systems can weaken confidence in the whole company.

From my articles / MarTech / August 27, 2026

A detailed profile can still describe the wrong person.

Where it went wrong: I requested my profile from an unnamed data broker. It contained 132 fields, many of them wrong. My criticism: a company could build and use a detailed version of me without a useful way for me to challenge its assumptions.

What a company could do differently

  1. Identity: Treat the person as a participant in understanding them.
  2. Intention: Distinguish what someone provided from what a system inferred, and give them a meaningful correction route.
  3. Implementation: Review one profile with the person it describes. Record corrections, pass them downstream, and measure whether the errors recur.
Read the original: Better data starts with treating people like people ↗

What I can help you do

Data practice review and team capability. Map the customer choices and responsibilities your team needs to honor. Scope privacy advice or technical changes with qualified specialists when required.

03

Brand accountability

Support your claims with current evidence.

Can your team show what supports the commitments your brand makes?

Start here

List your most visible claims. Give each one a supporting record, an owner, and a review date. Update the wording when the evidence changes.

See the consequences, example, and how I can help

How it strengthens your company

Claims your people can explain and support make your position easier to trust and your offer easier to choose.

What can weaken trust

Outdated claims or values that customers cannot see in practice can damage credibility and leave employees defending a promise they cannot deliver.

From my articles / MarTech / September 12, 2024

Starbucks: the gathering-place promise meets a different experience.

Where it went wrong: I argued that a shift toward digital transactions and aggressive promotions had weakened the welcoming coffeehouse experience that made Starbucks distinctive. The issue was the distance between its identity and the experience I encountered.

What a company could do differently

  1. Identity: Choose what a modern gathering place should mean to the people you serve.
  2. Intention: Give store teams concrete experience priorities alongside sales targets.
  3. Implementation: Test seating, service, and ordering changes in a small set of stores. Ask customers whether the experience supports the promise before scaling.
Read the original: The fading third place: A reflection on Starbucks and society ↗

What I can help you do

Brand strategy and positioning. Clarify what your company stands for, refine the offer, and create a customer promise your team can support with evidence.

04

Technology accountability

Make your technology helpful and understandable.

Can people understand an automated decision and reach someone who can review it?

Start here

Pick one automated customer interaction. Define what it can decide, what gets recorded, when a person intervenes, and who can correct an error.

See the consequences, example, and how I can help

How it strengthens your company

Useful automation, clear explanations, and human ownership can save time while keeping customers confident in the response.

What can weaken trust

Opaque decisions or automated loops can leave customers stuck and teams unable to explain what happened.

From my articles / These Are the Breaks / October 4, 2026

Parking apps: payment success should mean something.

Where it went wrong: I described navigating several parking apps and transaction fees, and linked Scarsdale’s acknowledgment that drivers had received tickets after paying through Pango. Technology intended to simplify compliance could still leave the user carrying the problem.

What a company could do differently

  1. Identity: Define success as a valid parking payment that enforcement recognizes.
  2. Intention: Agree who owns a mismatch between payment records and a ticket.
  3. Implementation: Connect receipts to a usable review process, reconcile payment and enforcement records, and test error recovery with the operator and municipality.
Read the original: Why Parking a Car Has Become a Part-Time Job ↗

What I can help you do

Workflow design and implementation support. Define the role of automation, human review, escalation, and ownership. Bring in technical specialists for agreed system changes.

05

Industry accountability

Use your market as a source of learning.

Are you learning from customer expectations and better practices across your industry?

Start here

Compare one policy or experience with two relevant peers. Look for practices worth adopting and a specific improvement your customers would value.

See the consequences, example, and how I can help

How it strengthens your company

A company that learns and raises its own standard can earn preference through a more useful experience.

What can weaken trust

Treating a familiar industry frustration as unavoidable can leave room for another company to offer something better.

From my articles / MarTech / May 16, 2025

Crumbl: trending content still needs a rights check.

Where it went wrong: I examined Warner Music Group’s lawsuit alleging unlicensed music use in Crumbl’s social content. The lesson was that a familiar industry shortcut does not establish permission. These were allegations discussed in that article, not a court finding presented here.

What a company could do differently

  1. Identity: Make respect for creators part of how the brand operates.
  2. Intention: Require documented rights clearance for brand and influencer content.
  3. Implementation: Assign an approval owner, keep a rights record, and have qualified counsel review uncertain uses before publication.
Read the original: Crumbl’s legal trouble shows the risks of shortcut marketing ↗

What I can help you do

Strategic Marketing Insights. Review relevant competitors, customer expectations, and available evidence so you can choose a useful point of difference.

06

Business accountability

Align incentives and ownership with your promise.

Do your targets and handoffs help people deliver the outcome you advertise?

Start here

Choose one recurring customer issue. Name an owner across the whole experience, review the targets involved, and agree what a completed outcome looks like.

See the consequences, example, and how I can help

How it strengthens your company

Clear ownership and incentives tied to customer outcomes help teams act together and follow through.

What can weaken trust

Targets that reward activity while leaving the customer’s issue open can create repeat work, internal friction, and lost confidence.

From my articles / MarTech / April 14, 2026

The dashboard looks good. What improved for the business?

Where it went wrong: I questioned my own corporate experience: titles and budgets could signal success while marketing remained distant from revenue. I argued that internal approval and impressive dashboards can distract a team from the offer, service, and economics that create value.

What a company could do differently

  1. Identity: Define the business and customer outcome marketing exists to support.
  2. Intention: Agree shared measures with sales, finance, and operations, including what those measures cannot prove.
  3. Implementation: Review one customer journey together. Fix an actual bottleneck and assess its effect alongside campaign activity.
Read the original: Marketing looks successful, but misses what matters ↗

What I can help you do

Leadership alignment and team development. Get the people responsible for the experience into the same decision. Agree ownership, operating instructions, and measures of progress.

07

Societal accountability

Connect public commitments to their effects on people.

Can you explain who benefits from a commitment and what evidence shows the result?

Start here

Choose one public commitment. Identify the people affected, the result you seek, how you will assess it, and when you will report progress.

See the consequences, example, and how I can help

How it strengthens your company

Specific commitments, visible progress, and a willingness to listen can give employees and communities a reason to believe your company.

What can weaken trust

Broad promises with little evidence or follow-through can create a credibility gap with the people you hoped to support.

From my articles / MarTech / February 14, 2025

Target: a public commitment needs an accountable next chapter.

Where it went wrong: In my analysis of Target’s DEI rollback, I argued that changing a highly visible commitment without a clear account of what would continue left employees and communities questioning the brand’s consistency. That is my assessment of the announcement at the time.

What a company could do differently

  1. Identity: State which commitments remain part of the company’s values.
  2. Intention: Explain what is changing, why, who is affected, and who owns the next steps.
  3. Implementation: Involve affected groups, publish specific actions and review dates, and report progress against those commitments.
Read the original: Target’s DEI retreat: Inclusivity was never more than a marketing stunt ↗

What I can help you do

Commitment review and progress planning. Make the intended impact specific, identify the people affected, and agree what evidence and reporting would support your commitment.

How we can work together

A defined starting point.
The right help to follow through.

You buy a clear piece of work with agreed outputs. The evidence determines which services you need.

Start here / Paid diagnostic

Customer Trust Diagnostic

We examine one customer workflow with your team using the seven principles and my three-step method.

  • Findings from the customer evidence
  • Up to three priorities with owners
  • Baseline measures and an implementation plan

Plan for about two weeks once the people and records are available. Scope, timing, and fee are agreed before starting.

See the diagnostic deliverables ↗

Put the plan to work / Separate scope

Implementation support

Turn the priorities into changes your team can use: a clearer offer, better handoffs, operating instructions, training, or an updated digital experience.

I lead the strategy and coordination. Your team or confirmed specialists handle agreed technical work.

See the services I bring ↗

Keep learning / Optional ongoing work

Progress reviews

Review what changed for customers, retest the corrections, and keep open actions moving.

Use a scorecard, action list, and review schedule tied to the outcomes you agreed.

Discuss ongoing support ↗

The principles guide the questions. Identity → Intention → Implementation guides how we work. The engagement defines what I will deliver and what your team will own.

Work with Jay

Want to do something about
your company’s trust gap?

Tell me which principle caught your attention and what you want to improve. We can discuss a Customer Trust Diagnostic, or the strategy, coaching, team development, and implementation support your situation calls for.

I lead the strategy and coordination, with specialists involved when the work calls for them. We agree on scope, responsibilities, timing, and fees before starting.

Start a conversation

How can I help?

Ask a question or share what you’re working through.

AI conversation · Opens SuperMeAsk Jay’s AIExplore Jay’s ideas with his SuperMe AI in a new tab.